The headline price is not what you take home. Deal structure decides that: how much is paid in cash at closing, how much is paid later, and how much depends on results you no longer control.
I spent the early part of my career making acquisitions for a major corporation. On the buy side, you learn that price is only one lever. Today I sit on the seller's side of the table, and the first thing I do with any letter of intent is take the headline number apart.
Two offers, side by side
Here are two offers for the same business. The numbers are an illustration, not a real deal.
| Offer A | Offer B | |
|---|---|---|
| Headline price | $5.0M | $5.5M |
| Cash at closing | $4.5M | $3.3M |
| EscrowReleased after 12 months if no claims | $0.5M | None |
| Seller notePaid over 5 years | None | $1.1M |
| EarnoutPaid only if profit targets are hit over 3 years | None | Up to $1.1M |
| In your account at closing | 90% | 60% |
Offer B is $500,000 higher on paper and $1.2 million lower on closing day. Of its $5.5 million, $2.2 million depends on the buyer: on them paying the note for five years, and on the business hitting targets after you've handed over the keys.
Offer B can still be the better deal. A strong buyer, a well-secured note and an earnout you're confident in can be worth the wait. But you should choose it knowing what it is, not because the first number was bigger.
The pieces of a deal
Cash at closing
The money wired to you the day the deal closes, after paying off any business debt. It's the only part of the price with no strings attached.
Seller note
You lend the buyer part of the purchase price and they pay you back over time, with interest. Notes are common in deals our size, and a note can show a lender that you believe in the business. The risk is that you are now a lender to someone else's company. If the buyer uses an SBA loan, the bank gets paid first, and its rules can limit when you get paid.
Earnout
Part of the price is paid later, but only if the business hits agreed targets after the sale. Earnouts can bridge a gap when you and the buyer disagree on what the business will do next. They also create disputes, because the buyer now controls the results that decide your payment. The definitions matter: revenue is harder to argue about than profit.
Escrow or holdback
Money set aside from the price, held for a set period after closing, to cover problems the buyer discovers later. You get it back if no claims are made. The size of the escrow, how long it's held and what counts as a claim are all negotiable.
Working capital target
Most deals require you to leave a "normal" level of working capital in the business at closing: receivables and inventory, less payables. If you deliver less than the target, the price drops dollar for dollar. Where that target is set is one of the quietest places a seller loses money, and it usually gets settled late in the deal, when you are tired and close to the finish line.
Asset sale or stock sale
Most buyers in our market prefer to buy assets. They get a fresh tax basis and leave old liabilities behind. Sellers often prefer to sell stock, because of how the gain is taxed. In an asset sale, how the price is divided among equipment, goodwill and a non-compete can change your tax bill, and your entity type matters too.
Two offers with the same headline price can leave you with very different amounts after taxes. Bring your CPA in before you sign the letter of intent, not after.
How buyers use structure to win on price
I've written offers from the buy side, so I know the move. A buyer who can't justify your number in cash will often agree to it on paper, then shift the risk back to you:
- A bigger earnout in place of cash, tied to targets that are hard to hit.
- A seller note with weak security, or one that waits behind the bank.
- A working capital target set high, so part of the price comes back at closing.
- A larger or longer escrow with broad terms for what counts as a claim.
- A retrade: agree to the price in the letter of intent, then lower it during due diligence, once you've stopped talking to other buyers.
None of these is unusual on its own. The question is whether they add up to the price you think you're getting. That's why we weigh every offer on terms, not just price.
Five questions to ask about any offer
- How much is wired to me at closing, after debt is paid off?
- What part of the price depends on future results, and who controls those results?
- If the buyer struggles, what protects the money they still owe me?
- What is the working capital target, and how was it calculated?
- What do I keep after taxes? Ask your CPA to run each offer.
Common questions
What is a normal earnout?
There is no standard earnout. The size, how long it runs and what it's tied to are all negotiated deal by deal. What matters most is that the targets are realistic, clearly defined, and measured in a way the buyer can't easily change after closing.
Should I accept a seller note?
Often, yes. Many buyers in the $1M to $20M range can't finance the full price, and a note can make the deal work. Before you agree, look at the interest rate, the payment schedule, what secures the note, and where it stands behind the bank.
What does "retrade" mean?
A retrade is when a buyer agrees to a price in the letter of intent, then tries to lower it during due diligence. It usually happens after you've signed exclusivity and stopped talking to other buyers. Good preparation is the best defense: problems you disclose up front can't be used to reopen the price later.
Have an offer on the table?
We'll take the headline number apart and show you what you actually keep, before you sign anything.
Talk to Garrett Call (888) 907-6201